ECONOMICS.
When freely available, you can download the publication by clicking on the image on the left
The Future of the Post-industrial Society. Individualism, Creativity and Entrepreneurship
Fellow: David Emanuel Andersson abstract & keywords
Abstract: This book studies the ongoing transition from an industrial to a creative (or post-industrial) society and how the creative society depends on a ‘soft infrastructure’ of individualist values and institutions. It explains this by looking first at the key actors in the creative society: creative individuals and entrepreneurial individuals, using insights from social and cognitive psychology and the economic theory of entrepreneurship. It shows how individual creativity and entrepreneurship are supported by both cultural individualism, based on the work of political scientists Ronald Inglehart and Christian Welzel, as well as political individualism, the principles of a democratic market economy guided by classical liberalism. The book offers a number of policy implications that result from the connection of this multidisciplinary reconceptualization of individualism to economic creativity. It discusses a system of property rights that accommodates the creation of new property, ranging from the result of what we normally think of as product innovation to larger-scale innovations embodied in the formation of new lifestyle communities. It also considers examples such as universities that are more open to experimentation and more autonomous from government regulation, and a more liberal immigration policy that may result from the positive association between population diversity and creativity. This book is intended to support further interdisciplinary and multidisciplinary research on the creative society (also known as post-industrialism, the postmodern society or the knowledge-based society). It will be of interest to academics and postgraduate students working in political economy, entrepreneurship, institutional economics, Austrian economics, and public policy. Keywords: creativity, post-industrial society, creative society, cultural and political individualism, entrepreneurship, innovation, classical liberalism, creative economy. |
Entrepreneurship in superdiverse societies and the end of one-sizefits-all policy prescriptions
Fellow: David Emanuel Andersson Authors, abstract & keywords
Authors: David Emanuel Andersson, Dieter Bögenhold, Marek Hudik Abstract: Purpose – The purpose of this paper is to explore the entrepreneurial and policy consequences of the structural changes associated with postindustrialization. Design/methodology/approach – The approach uses Schumpeterian and institutional theories to predict the consequences of postindustrialization on four types of innovative markets: global mass markets; global niche markets; local mass markets and local niche markets. Findings – The paper makes two key predictions. First, global mass markets will account for most costcutting process innovations. Second, niche markets, whether global or local, will provide the bulk of product innovations. Opportunities for product innovations in niche markets multiply both as the result of a more complex economy and as the result of heterogeneous preferences of consumers with divergent learning trajectories. Social implications – The key implication of the theoretical pattern prediction of this paper is that there are increasing opportunities for entrepreneurs to introduce novelties that cater to niche demands, and this includes new lifestyle communities. The increasing diversity of values and preferences implies that one-size-fit-all policies are becoming increasingly inimical to the entrepreneurial discovery of higher-valued resource uses. Originality/value – This paper takes a standard prediction of entrepreneurial theories – that innovations become more common with an increase in economy-wide product complexity – and extends this to increasing complexity on the consumption side. With increases in opportunities for learning, consumers diverge and develop disparate lifestyles. The resultant super-diversity, which multiplies consumption niches to a much greater extent than what ethnicity-based diversity indices would imply, makes it more difficult to achieve consensus about the desirability of public policies. Keywords: Mass markets, Niche markets, Globalization, Schumpeter, Connoisseurship |
Rational expectations equilibria of economies with local interactions
Fellow: Alberto Bisin Authors, abstract & keywords
Authors: Alberto Bisin, Ulrich Horst, Onur Özgür Abstract: We consider general economies in which rational agents interact locally. The local aspect of the interactions is designed to represent in a simple abstract way social interactions, that is, socioeconomic environments in which markets do not mediate all of agents’ choices, which might be in part determined, for instance, by family, peer group, or ethnic group effects. We study static as well as dynamic infinite horizon economies; we allow for economies with incomplete information, and we consider jointly global and local interactions, to integrate e.g., global externalities and markets with peer and group effects. We provide conditions under which such economies have rational expectations equilibria.We illustrate the effects of local interactions when agents are rational by studying in detail the equilibrium properties of a simple economy with quadratic preferences which captures, in turn, local preferences for conformity, habit persistence, and preferences for status or adherence to aggregate norms of behavior. Keywords: Rational expectations; Local interactions, Existence of equilibria |
The Economics of Cultural Transmission and the Dynamics of Preferences
Fellow: Alberto Bisin Authors & abstract
Authors: Alberto Bisin, Thierry Verdier Abstract: This paper studies the population dynamics of preference traits in a model of intergenerational cultural transmission. Parents socialize and transmit their preferences to their offspring, motivated by a form of paternalistic altruism ("imperfect empathy"). In such a setting we study the long run stationary state pattern of preferences in the population, according to various socialization mechanisms and institutions, and identify sufficient conditions for the global stability of an heterogenous stationary distribution of the preference traits. We show that cultural transmission mechanisms have very different implications than evolutionary selection mechanisms with respect to the dynamics of the distribution of the traits in the population, and we study mechanisms which interact evolutionary selection and cultural transmission. |
On the Joint Evolution of Culture and Institutions: Elites and Civil Society
Fellows: Alberto Bisin Authors & abstract
Authors: Alberto Bisin, Thierry Verdier Abstract: In this paper we provide an abstract modeling of the interaction between culture and institutions and their e ects on economic variables of interest, notably, e.g., long-run economic activity. We characterize conditions on the socio-economic environment such that culture and institutions complement (resp. substitute) each other, giving rise to a multiplier e ect which ampli es (resp. dampens) their combined ability to spur socio-economic activity. We show how the joint dynamics of culture and institutions may display interesting non-ergodic behavior, hysteresis, oscillations, depending on the form of the interaction between culture and institutions. The model can be specialized to study the political economy of elites and civil society for the determination of long-run socio-economic activity in di erent contexts. We illustrate this by studying the transition away from extractive institutions and the formation of civic capital in two example societies. |
Smith’s paradox of price and negotiation: Empirical evidence from India
Fellow: Sattwick Dey Biswas abstract
Abstract: Diamond-water paradox has enticed the human mind for generations. Adam Smith gave it a new twist in the Wealth of Nations that serves as the basis of all modern valuation theories. This paper goes back to the original writing of Smith to identify paradoxes and then empirical test in the context of land value. The review of original texts and empirical evidence suggests the existence of a third principle, i.e. “riches and poverty of those who demand”. This indication demands a re-evaluation of Smith’s paradox of value and has implication of modern science of valuation. |
I Choose for Myself, Therefore I Am: The Contours of Existentialist Behavioral Economics
Fellow: Malte Dold Authors, abstract & keywords
Authors: Malte Dold, Alexa Stanton Abstract: Behavioral economics and existentialism both present informa-tive perspectives on human choice. We argue in this article that the dia-logue between the two approaches can enrich the current debate about the normative implications of behavioral economics. While behavioral economics suggests that our capacity to choose is constrained by cogni-tive biases and environmental influences, existentialism emphasizes that we can (and should) treat ourselves as free and ‘becoming’ beings in spite of the many constraints we face. Acknowledging these two perspectives in the form of a theoretical synthesis—which we propose to call existen-tialist behavioral economics—provides us with reasons why we should protect our choices ‘as our own’ and how doing so may be more difficult than we anticipate. It also provides a framework to analyze the threat of identity-shaping social and technological developments, such as prefer-ence-altering nudges and artificially intelligent prediction algorithms. Keywords: agency, authenticity, behavioral economics, nudging, choice, existentialism, freedom, identity, meaning |
Old Chicago against Static Welfare Economics
Fellow: Malte Dold Authors & abstract
Authors: Malte Dold, Mario J. Rizzo Abstract: Although behavioral economists have criticized the empirical accuracy of the neoclassical rationality assumption, they support the normative view that welfare-increasing choice presupposes stable, context-independent preferences. We argue that this position neglects important features of decision-making that were essential to the thinking of Frank H. Knight and James M. Buchanan (Old Chicago economics). Knight and Buchanan embrace the idea that well-integrated preferences are an intellectual construct that cannot be the normative basis for welfare assessments. They argue that the only trait that is stable in real time and across individuals is the urge to have some vaguely defined better preferences. In other words, exploring, learning, and being contradictory and ambivalent are all part of the process both before and after a temporary maximization. We illustrate their view, present some empirical evidence, and discuss the normative implications especially for the character of a liberal social order such as Richard Epstein has advocated. |
A neglected topos in behavioural normative economics: the opportunity and process aspect of freedom
Fellow: Malte Dold Authors, abstract & keywords
Authors: Malte Dold, Paul Lewis Abstract: Robert Sugden has advanced various critiques of behavioural welfare economics, offering the notion of opportunity as an alternative. We agree with much of Sugden’s critique but argue that his approach would benefit from a broadening of the informational base beyond opportunities to include people’s concern for decision processes. We follow Amartya Sen in arguing that the process through which choices are made (process freedom) is something individuals care about beyond the availability of choice options (opportunity freedom) as they value a sense of agency. We argue that individuals’ agentic capabilities are crucial for people’s process freedom and hence for their sense of agency. In the final section of the paper, we sketch the institutional implications of our argument, i.e. what a joint consideration of opportunities and agentic capabilities means for behavioural public policy. Keywords: Amartya Sen; agency; behavioral public policy; opportunities; process freedom; Robert Sugden |
Contractarian ideology and the legitimacy of government
Fellow: Randall G. Holcombe abstract & keywords
Abstract: Social contract theory depicts a constitutional contract as the result of a hypothetical agreement among society’s members to escape a prisoners’ dilemma situation. It depicts citizens as political equals agreeing to be forced into a cooperative strategy rather than a socially suboptimal strategy that gives them the highest personal payoff. Government is the organization that forces everyone to cooperate. However, citizens can never bargain as political equals. An elite few design the rules, and others are forced to comply with them. The contractarian ideology that depicts government as acting in the general public interest legitimizes the actions of government, giving those elite few who hold government power a greater ability to use it to further their own interests, often at the expense of the masses. Within the context of a prisoners’ dilemma game, contractarian ideology leads to an outcome that is socially suboptimal, but beneficial for the political elite. Keywords: Social contract; prisoners’ dilemma; legitimacy of government; Thomas Hobbes; John Locke, Jean Jacques Rousseau; John Rawls; James M. Buchanan |
Progressive Democracy: the ideology of the modern predatory state
Fellow: Randall G. Holcombe abstract & keywords
Abstract: The state must expend resources to credibly threaten the use of force, and the actual use of force is more costly than just exercising the threat. A population that views itself as prey to a predatory state will resist the state’s demands and will not produce much that the state can appropriate. The predatory state will be more successful if it can convince its citizens that the state’s activities are in the public interest, which will enhance voluntary compliance with the state’s mandates and lessen the need for the state to invest resources in overt coercion. The ideology of “Progressive Democracy” encourages citizens to cooperate with the state, and legitimizes the state’s predatory activities. The ideology of Progressivism justifies the imposition of costs on some for the benefit of others. The ideology of democracy implies that when a democratic government does this, it is acting in the public interest. Keywords: Democracy, Progressivism, Predatory state, Contractarianism, Political ideology, Politics as exchange |
The economic theory of rights
Fellow: Randall G. Holcombe abstract & keywords
Abstract: People have rights to the degree that they are willing to claim them and are able to enforce them, either themselves or through a third-party enforcer. This economic theory of rights is based on the rights people actually do have and are able to exercise, not the rights they should have based on some normative criteria. Natural rights theories and contractual rights theories are examined and found to be ambiguous as to the actual rights they imply. Furthermore, there is no assurance that people will actually be able to exercise any natural rights or agreed-upon rights. People’s actual ability to claim and enforce rights is based on the economic and political power they have, which in turn is based on their ability to provide benefits to others in exchange for others respecting the claimed rights, and in some cases being willing to use force to make others respect them. |
Land Planning, Property Rights and Management of Built Heritage: Some Hong Kong Observations of Colonial Military Buildings
Fellow: Lawrence W. C. Lai Authors, abstract & keywords
Authors: Lawrence W. C. Lai, Stephen N. G. Davies,Lennon H. T. Choy, K. W. Chau Abstract: There has been much confusion in property rights inquiry into real (immovable) property (i.e., land) between open access and common property, and between public property and common property because that is often also open access. This paper argues that the property rights and access control are two distinct dimensions of land resource management. Access control involves the exercise of exclusionary power relevant to the management of the immovable property (property management) for its optimal use. A review of the literature shows that definitions of property management tend to be too narrow but point towards the need to articulate issues within the property rights paradigm. As a contribution to sustainable resource use as a dimension of land planning, this paper points out and discusses the probable sources of the confusion between land property rights and property management. A “Land Property Rights and Management Matrix” (LPRMM) is developed as a theoretical tool for clarifying the confusion and the relationships amongst relevant concepts. The LPRMM is theoretically informed by Barzel’s not entirely correct distinction between legal (de jure) and economic (de facto) rights and enriched by relevant literature on property rights and property management. Practical use of the LPRMM is illustrated by its application to analyze the issues pertaining to the actual resource-use phenomena in colonial military buildings erected on both private and public land in Hong Kong. The results show that heritage buildings on land under public ownership as private property can be neglected or intensively managed. The LPRMM is not only a useful theoretical tool for precisely assessing the actual affairs of resource use but also a practical tool for identifying issues of property management in its widest sense. The LPRMM offered is a proper interpretation of Barzel’s distinction between legal and economic rights and contributes to systematically re-interpreting property management as town planning writ large in terms of de jure property rights and de facto access. Keywords: town planning; property management; property rights; access restrictions; built heritage |
Land Surveying and Squatting
Fellow: Lawrence W. C. Lai Authors, abstract & keywords
Authors: Lawrence W. C. Lai, K. W. Chau Abstract: Although its scale and social implications depend on the specific country or local situations, squatting is a global urban and rural phenomenon associated with such humanitarian issues as social justice, poverty and environmental impact, as well as economic issues, such as rent seeking by certain groups. It can be sporadic or massive. The state appears to deal with the former by implementing legal rules and the latter with social policies. With regard to the economic gains and costs of allowing squatting, it can be argued that squatter policies, which confer some entitlements on squatters, are akin to the doctrine of adverse possession in equity through recognising the benefits of long-term possession of land. Surveying and mapping as a key tool in the regulation of squatters in this context may or may not be carried out, contrary to common belief. This paper demonstrates, with documented real-world examples from Australia and China, that the state surveying of massive urban or rural squatting on government land is contingent on the benefits and costs of tolerating squatting. The discussion is related to the transfer of development rights (TDR) as a practicable inclusive policy in the context of a global drive towards land assembly for real estate development, which squatters often obstruct. Keywords: squatting; land surveying and mapping; property rights; rent seeking; transfer of development rights (TDR) |
'No property is an island': the private lot as the basic unit of landuse planning & management of a wider world
Fellow: Lawrence W. C. Lai abstract & keywords
Abstract: Informed by basic neo-institutional economic and property law concepts, this essay points out that private property in the form of a lot is rarely an isolated piece of land due to the social nature of private property of land; and explains that private property rights of land necessarily include the negative rights not to use, to derive income or alienate. The distinction between de jure rights & duties and de facto access conditions is useful; and the number of individuals on land should not affect the nature of private property though it may affect its use. Reference is made to an interesting re-interpretation of The Tale of Peter Rabbit by Blomley. Keywords: Private property rights, exclusivity, negative rights, lot, layout, spatial division of labour |
Economic Rewards to Motivate Blood Donations
Fellow: Mario Macis Authors & abstract
Authors: Nicola Lacetera , Mario Macis, Robert Slonim Abstract: The position and guidelines of the World Health Organization (WHO) and several national blood collection agencies for nearly 40 years have been based on the view that offering economic incentives to blood donors is detrimental to the quantity and safety of the blood supply (1). The guidelines suggest that blood should be obtained from unpaid volunteers only (2). However, whether economic incentives positively or negatively affect blood donations (and other prosocial activities) has remained the subject of debate since the positions were established (2–8). Evidence consistent with the WHO position came originally from uncontrolled studies using nonrandom samples and, subsequently, from surveys and laboratory studies indicating that economic incentives can “crowd out” (decrease) intrinsic motivations to donate and can attract “worse” donors (9). This evidence arguably affected policies, such as bans on compensation for blood and organ donations in many countries. Surveys allow for a variety of hypothetical manipulations on large samples, and laboratory experiments parallel laboratory health research methods by enabling researchers to carefully control the setting, randomize the assignment of treatment, and identify causal effects. Because compensation is illegal in many countries and observing blood donations is often costly (as only a small share of subjects invited to donate actually do so), surveys and laboratory studies retain an important role for addressing many questions (10). Yet it is unusual for health policy to rely only on such evidence. Complementary, randomized field trials are the norm and are recommended before policies are affected (11). With a few early exceptions based on small, nonrepresentative samples (12), field trial evidence on how economic incentives affect blood donations has been absent. But field-based evidence from large, representative samples has recently emerged. The results are clear and, on important questions, opposite to the uncontrolled studies, surveys, and laboratory evidence preceding them. |
Paying for Kidneys? A Randomized Survey and Choice Experiment
Fellow: Mario Macis Authors, abstract & keywords
Authors: Julio J. Elias, Nicola Lacetera, Mario Macis Abstract: We conducted a randomized survey with 2,666 US residents to study preferences for legalizing payments to kidney donors. We found strong polarization, with many participants supporting or opposing payments regardless of potential transplant gains. However, about 18 percent of respondents would switch to favoring payments for sufficiently large increases in transplants. Preferences for compensation have strong moral foundations; participants especially reject direct payments by patients, which they find would violate principles of fairness. We corroborate the interpretation of our findings with a choice experiment of a costly decision to donate money to a foundation that supports donor compensation. |
Sacred Values? The Effect of Information on Attitudes toward Payments for Human Organs
Fellow: Mario Macis Authors & abstract
Authors: Julio J. Elias, Nicola Lacetera, Mario Macis Abstract: Are attitudes about morally controversial (and often prohibited) market transactions affected by information about their costs and benefits? We address this question for the case of payments for human organs. We find in a survey experiment with US residents (N=3,417) that providing information on the potential efficiency benefits of a regulated price mechanism for organs significantly increased support for payments from a baseline of 52 percent to 71 percent. The survey was devised to minimize social desirability biases in responses, and additional analyses validate the interpretation that subjects were reflecting on the case-specific details provided, rather than just reacting to any information. |
Untangling the commons: three different forms of commonality
Fellow: Stefano Moroni abstract & keywords
Abstract: The term “commons” is used with increasing frequency in the public debate and scientific literature in various fields (including economics and sociology). However, this term is often ambiguous and used to denote quite different things. Obviously, any concept, and therefore also the concept of “commons”, does not have an “essence”. Clear definitions do not serve to capture what something is in itself, but only to rigorously specify what use is made of a given expression. In other words, linguistic precision is not a value in itself, but becomes necessary when misunderstandings can arise – as happens in the case under discussion. This article critically revisits the notion itself of “commons”. It is based on an extensive interdisciplinary literature review. However, the intent is not to provide an overview of the state of the art but to suggest a critical reframing of the discourse. The overall aim is not solely to distinguish different uses of the term; it is also to clarify the real scope and meaning of each definition of it – such as the one proposed by Elinor Ostrom, which is too often inappropriately invoked. As the article demonstrates, Ostrom’s view on many issues perfectly aligns with the Hayekian account of the evolutionary, emerging nature of a significant number of successful institutions and forms of organization. Keywords: Commons, Institutionalism, Ostrom, Hayek, Evolution |
The Contemporary Economic Costs of Spatial Chaos: Evidence from Poland
Fellow: Maciej Nowak Authors, abstract & keywords
Authors: Przemysław Śleszyński, Adam Kowalewski, Tadeusz Markowski,Paulina Legutko-Kobus, Maciej Nowak Abstract: This paper is based on the results of an extensive (840-page) report of the Committee on National Spatial Development of the Polish Academy of Sciences, entitled Studies on Spatial Chaos (edited by A. Kowalewski, T, Markowski and P. ´Sleszy ´nski—Studia KPZK PAN, vol. 182,Warsaw 2018—in Polish). Its aim was to conduct a comprehensive and detailed study on the problem of spatial chaos (spatial disorder), including an estimate of economic costs in Poland. For this purpose, literature was queried (articles and reports, etc.) and special analyses were prepared for this purpose. The total annual costs of spatial chaos were estimated at not less than 20 billion euros per year. The conclusions also proposed solutions and suggestions (for the government and local governments), which may reduce the acute costs of spatial chaos in society and economy. Keywords: spatial chaos; spatial disorder; costs of spatial chaos; quality of life; Poland |
Investments in Renewable Energy Sources in the Concepts of Local Spatial Policy: The Case of Poland
Fellow: Maciej Nowak Authors, abstract & keywords
Authors: Małgorzata Blaszke, Maciej Nowak, Przemysław Śleszyński, Bartosz Mickiewicz Abstract: The paper aims to determine the role and formula of investments in renewable energy sources in Poland’s concepts of local spatial policies. It analyses 12,777 planning documents of local spatial policy (these are resolutions adopted by municipalities—in Poland there are two types of these instruments: studies of spatial development conditions and directions and local spatial development plans) in Poland enacted in 2005–2020. On this basis, local concepts were classified and related to the geographical and functional characteristics of municipalities. Poland is an interesting case study in this respect, providing a good reference point for broader international considerations. It was found that only 58.4% of Polish municipalities include renewable energy sources in their spatial policy concept. These are definitely more often urbanised municipalities. The degree of approach to renewable energy sources is also determined by the location of the municipality in the given province. The authors diagnose serious weaknesses in the Polish spatial planning system, consisting in the lack of skilful implementation of renewable energy sources into it. This is one of the reasons for the weaker development of renewable energy sources in the country. The authors consider as an innovative element of the research the analysis of the content of all spatial policy instruments in a given country, from the perspective of renewable energy sources, including proposing a way to verify these instruments. Keywords: renewable energy sources; spatial policy; spatial policy tools; investment efficiency |
Economic Consequences of Adopting Local Spatial Development Plans for the Spatial Management System: The Case of Poland
Fellow: Maciej Nowak Authors, abstract & keywords
Authors: Przemysław Śleszyński, Maciej Nowak,Paweł Sudra, Magdalena Załęczna, Małgorzata Blaszke Abstract: The spatial management system in Poland struggles with serious costs as a consequence of local planning. The problem is the lack of appropriate value capturing mechanisms and cost compensation for municipalities, along with significant burdens. Private property is subject to special protection, but the public good is less valued. The article attempts to assess the situation in Poland, recalling also the experiences of spatial management systems from other European countries. It combines legal, economic, and geographical perspectives. The specific objectives were demonstration of geographical (interregional and functional) regularities related to the economic (financial) consequences of adopting local plans and identification of financial effects resulting from the implementation of local plans in communes, i.e., in particular, their size, structure of revenues (income), and expenditures, in relations with the budgets of municipalities and the population living in communes. First, the determinants of spatial policy were defined in the context of institutional economics and the real estate market. Then, a unique database of forecasted and realized budgetary revenues and expenditures of 2477 communes in Poland related to spatial development (infrastructure construction, land transformation, purchase, etc.) was analyzed statistically. Additionally, for five selected communes of different functional types, this issue was examined in detail. It has been shown that municipalities do not derive adequate income from spatial development, and improper policy of local self-governments results in heavy burdens, threatening to disturb their financial balance. The formulated conclusions regarding the legal, economic, and spatial mechanisms may contribute to building tools (instruments) for more effective spatial management in various countries. Keywords: local development; local law; budgets of local units; financial consequences of spatial chaos |
Foucault and Hayek on public health and the road to serfdom
Fellow: Mark Pennington abstract & keywords
Abstract: This paper draws on the work of Michel Foucault and Friedrich Hayek to understand threats to personal and enterprise freedom, arising from public health governance. Whereas public choice theory examines the incentives these institutions provide to agents, the analysis here understands those incentives as framed by discursive social constructions that affect the identity, power, and positionality of different actors. It shows how overlapping discourses of scientific rationalism may generate a ‘road to serfdom’ narrowing freedom of action and expression across an expanding terrain. As such, the paper contributes to the growing literature emphasising the importance of narratives, stories and metaphors as shaping political economic action in ways feeding through to outcomes and institutions. Keywords: Foucault, Hayek, Public health, Social constructionism, Narrative political economy |
Hayek on complexity, uncertainty and pandemic response
Fellow: Mark Pennington abstract & keywords
Abstract: This paper draws on Hayek’s distinction between simple and complex phenomena to understand the nature of the challenge facing policymakers in responding to the new coronavirus pandemic. It shows that while government action is justifiable there may be few systemic mechanisms that enable policymakers to distinguish better from worse policy responses, or to make such distinctions in sufficient time. It then argues that this may be a more general characteristic of large-scale public policy making procedures and illustrates the importance of returning to a market-based political economy at the earliest convenience. Keywords: Hayek, Pandemics, Complexity, Uncertainty, Public policy |
Robust Political Economy and the Priority of Markets
Fellow: Mark Pennington abstract & keywords
Abstract: This essay offers a “nonideal” case for giving institutional priority to markets and private contracting in the basic structure of society. It sets out a “robust political economy” framework to examine how different political economic regime types cope with frictions generated by the epistemic limitations of decision-makers and problems of incentive incompatibility. Focusing on both efficiency arguments and distributive justice concerns the essay suggests that a constitutional structure that prioritizes consensual exchange is more likely to sustain a cooperative venture for mutual advantage. Keywords: Nonideal theory, robust political economy, markets, democracy, comparative institutions |
Hayekian Political Economy and the Limits of Deliberative Democracy
Fellow: Mark Pennington abstract
Abstract: Inspired by Habermasian critiques of liberalism, supporters of deliberative democracy seek an extension of social democratic institutions to further a reinvigorated communicative rationality against the ‘atomism’ of market processes. This paper offers a critique of deliberative democratic theory from a Hayekian perspective. For Hayek, the case against the social democratic state rests with the superior capacity of markets to extend communicative rationality beyond the realm of verbal discourse. |